Adjusting to a new environment never comes easily. Our bodies will eventually adapt to seasonal climate changes, travelling to different time zones, or high altitude, but it invariably takes some time, and involves a little discomfort along the way. Adjustments of any kind are easier if anticipated and understood in advance.
Medical school is an adjustment and, unfortunately, not always anticipated by those “taking the plunge”.
What’s the most difficult adjustment for first year medical students?
Asked that question, most would point to issues such as workload, engaging initial patient encounters, or perhaps aspects of technical competence involving physical examination or procedures. All important, to be sure, but these challenges are understood in advance, anticipated by our curriculum, and well within the abilities of the young people entering medicine, who are already very accomplished and have engaged the process and been selected with all these issues firmly in mind.
Beyond these anticipated challenges, there are other adjustments that are even more critical to success but much less well-appreciated or even unanticipated by students.
Why do we undertake educational programs? For many undergraduate university students, it is to either to pursue an area of personal interest, or to achieve prerequisites or qualification for a subsequent program. That’s certainly the case for students contemplating entry to medical school. These are certainly worthy goals, but they are personal and intended to promote individual objectives. In a professional program such as medicine, the goals of learning shift to encompass the interests of other parties, specifically future patients. The approach and motivation for learning must also shift. In the words of an astute former mentor “Medicine is a service industry”. Medical school is about preparing young people to provide that service. The learning is facilitated by that goal. In fact, it can’t occur without it.
Students entering medical school have achieved much recognition for their academic and personal accomplishments, the most recent and notable being their success in the admission process. As they undertake their studies together with equally accomplished classmates and in a system that defines success simply as “pass” with very little numerical grading, external kudos and other tangible evidence of success become increasingly rare. The perception of success must therefore shift from the external to internal as will, eventually, the responsibility for ensuring they remain knowledgeable and technically competent.
The expectation of professional behaviour
Medical education is patient-centred. Students learn early that their interactions with patients must be carried out with high standards of confidentiality, respect and personal behaviour. Although that expectation is easily understood within the patient contact itself, it is perhaps less immediately understood that the same expectations are in play with all their interpersonal and social interactions. The lines between their personal and student lives therefore become blurred. For most, this is a novel experience, and perhaps the first realization of what it means to have engaged a professional role.
Dealing with uncertainty
Students, particularly those from backgrounds in the physical or biologic sciences, have come to expect precision and certainty in their studies. The concept of “right” and “wrong” provides reassuring clarity and promotes the expectation that learning is a finite endeavor, culminating with the discovery of that single, correct response. In the study of medicine, they find a much less dichotomous world where many clinical issues are nuanced and require interpretation based on many variables. They must develop “approaches” based on “best evidence” always contextualized to the “patient’s unique circumstances”. For those accustomed to singular solutions, this can be quite unsettling.
All this can sound quite daunting but, like any life adjustment, will be eased with patience and support. Fortunately, much support is available. The quick “bonding” with classmates allows for the comforting realization that these challenges are not unique or some critical personal shortcoming, but rather ubiquitous features of the early medical school experience. Interactions with upper class colleagues, both planned and informal, provide further validation. Our Student Affairs programs, mentor groups, observerships and Clinical Skills groups all provide opportunities to discuss transition difficulties.
In the end, the adjustment is not merely about engaging a new educational program, but rather a more clearly defined identity and perspective of one’s role in the world.