Teaching the Way You Practice: Collaborative Active Learning in Different Teaching Settings

Post Thumbnail

By Michelle Gibson (gibson@queensu.ca) and Melissa Andrew (andrewm@providencecare.ca)

Most health professionals are actively engaged in collaborative practice: working with many different team members from different disciplines to support patients or clients in achieving their health goals.

However, we often teach our learners in isolation from one another, and, if we are being honest, co-teaching and integration between disciplines in an educational setting can be challenging.  When it ‘works’, however, it is very rewarding, and it is an opportunity to role-model explicitly for learners how different disciplines with differing approaches can work together to enhance care. When co-teaching is combined with active learning that mimics the wonderful messiness of real clinical practice, learners can start to envision how complex problems are approached in “real-life”.  In our experience, this is particularly powerful when we have students also working in teams on complex, real-world cases.

We offer up tips and lessons learned in six years shared teaching between geriatric medicine and geriatric psychiatry in undergraduate and post-graduate settings, to different audiences. We have also co-taught with other health care disciplines but our examples come from our co-teaching.

Examples of what we teach together:

  • Second year medical students:  We built on-line modules for students to use first on dementia and delirium, and then we co-teach the session that applies this learning to real-life cases.  Dr. Andrew co-teaches a 2nd session on “Brain and Behaviour” with a psychogeriatric resource consultant.
  • Family Medicine residents: We have 2 half-days which deal with common, complex, outpatient problems in older adults: the patient who arrives on a Friday afternoon with falls, confusion, and a letter from an anxious daughter; the patient who is extremely cognitively impaired, falling frequently, with a nightmarish medication list, and no family members who can provide history; this same patient who has a valid drivers’ license, and who may or may not be depressed.

top-tips

Tip # 1:  Start with being clear about your purpose(s), goals, objectives.

While this is important for all teaching, it becomes essential when more than one individual is involved.  For example, when we started to design academic half-days for family medicine residents, we worked out that we were aiming to help them approach complex patients with multiple problems in an outpatient setting, while highlighting how geriatric psychiatry and geriatric medicine are similar, how they are different, and how we work together.  These sessions work best with a shared vision.

Tip #2:  Be explicit about roles and expectations.

Similar to Tip #1, this does get increasingly complex when more than one (extremely passionate and very dedicated) teacher is involved in any learning event.  Who is preparing what? By when? How are the different parts going to be taught?  There is nothing worse than realizing the day before that you were the one expected to prepare the quiz. J

Tip #3:  Avoid ‘parallel play’.

Some attempts at integration or co-teaching end up being a series of lectures or teaching sessions that happen to be scheduled in approximately the same time period and are not really integrated.   The best sessions involve a back-and-forth approach, with many opportunities to address areas of controversy in a respectful manner. (See Tip #4)

Tip #4:  Embrace controversy, respectfully.

Junior learners in particular, in our experience, become stressed when it appears there is no one “right” answer.  We live, wallow, and celebrate the land of the gray-zone in geriatrics (pun intended), so we rarely have one correct answer.  However, how we address this in our teaching is important.  We frequently check in with one another: “How would you approach this in your setting?” and acknowledge strengths in differing approaches.

Tip #5:  Embrace complexity, carefully.

We have been pleasantly surprised as to how groups of learners are able to work together to approach very complex cases, when there is a safe learning environment.  For example, we give learners a very complex medication list, while providing an approach for them to practice, and we emphasize that there are many ‘right’ answers.  When we debrief this exercise, we use our different backgrounds/expertise to help students navigate the pros and cons of different decisions.  The team setting for teaching appears to allow students to feel safe to address areas of discomfort – that wondrous gray zone in which we revel. We all consult when there is a great deal of complexity, and we should role-model this for our learners.

Tip #6:  Play your best cards.

This is a great time to determine who is best at which parts, and use these skills to your advantage.  This applies both to clinical expertise, but also to teaching styles: who is the best person to teach X? Who is better at addressing this particular issue?  Why not compensate for each other’s’ weaknesses? You also have the huge benefit of learning from your colleague.

lessons-learned

Lesson #1:  It takes more time up front, but less time the more you do it.  The discussions, planning, negotiations about “what is the way we want to approach X” does require more time initially, but it gets easier each time.

Lesson #2: If possible, it’s best (in our opinion), and more fun, to co-teach with people that you work with regularly. The established trust and long-standing respectful relationships, we believe, shine through for learners, allowing them to feel comfortable when we ‘disagree’ on certain issues.  This is much easier to do in a collegial way when you know how the other teachers work and think.  Plus, teaching with friends is fun.

Lesson #3:  Going out for lunch to plan teaching is optimal.  ‘Nuff said.  Seriously, though – it’s hard to plan teaching in the midst of busy clinical work.  Set aside time to think about things, and to meet in a positive environment.

Lesson #4:  Where there is assessment involved, co-marking is hugely informative – as in, set aside time, sit down together, and mark together.  It allows us to delve into why students thought X, when clearly we thought we were teaching Y.  There is also the distinct advantage of being able to share the marking load, whilst sipping on pleasant beverages.  More importantly, though, by discussing the answers, we are able to immediately adapt our teaching plans for the following year.

 

 

 

One Response to Teaching the Way You Practice: Collaborative Active Learning in Different Teaching Settings

  1. Karen Smith says:

    Very nice piece Drs. Gibson and Andrew. Great tips. We should all attend to these.

Leave a Reply to Karen Smith Cancel reply

Post Timeline

Mentorship isn’t rocket science – or is it?
Published Mon, October 16, 2017

One of the most consequential communications in modern history took the form a letter sent by Albert Einstein to American President Franklin Roosevelt on August 2, 1939. “Sir: Some recent work by E. Fermi and L. Szilard, which has been communicated to me in manuscript, leads me to expect that the element uranium may be turned into a new and … Continue reading

Meet Jenna Healey, the new Hannah Chair in the History of Medicine
Published Mon, October 9, 2017

The new Jason A. Hannah Chair in the History of Medicine knows most Queen’s medical students aren’t going to memorize historical dates and events as a matter of routine, and that’s perfectly okay. Dr. Jenna Healey notes that instead focusing on dry facts – that these days can readily be looked up — one excellent use of history is “to … Continue reading

Curriculum Committee Information – July 27, 2017
Published Mon, October 2, 2017

Faculty and staff interested in attending Curriculum Committee meetings should contact the Committee Secretary, Candace Miller (umecc@queensu.ca), for information relating to agenda items and meeting schedules. A meeting of the Curriculum Committee was held on July 27, 2017.  To review the topics discussed at this meeting, please click HERE to view the agenda. Faculty interested in reviewing the minutes of the July … Continue reading

From campus to community: the Loving Spoonful Service Learning Project
Published Mon, October 2, 2017

By Steven Bae and Lauren Wilson, MEDS 2019 “Let food be thy medicine, and medicine be thy food” – Hippocrates Food. It is a vital part of our existence, and is a focal point in many cultures. Over the course of one year, a person who eats three meals a day consumes 1092 meals. It plays such a large role … Continue reading

The Meds 2019 Clinical Clerks hit the streets.
Published Mon, September 25, 2017

Here they come. This week, the class of Meds 2019 begin their Clinical Clerkship. Although this is only the half-way point in their medical education, it is a highly significant milestone, marking transition from a program dominated by largely classroom based knowledge and skills acquisition, to “real life” learning in a variety of clinical placements and elective experiences. Last Friday, … Continue reading